Highly recommended
3 critic mentions
Updated August 2026
Critic Recognition
EaterEaterEssential2023-06-15
“St. Elmo Steak House remains an Indianapolis institution known for its legendary shrimp cocktail and prime steaks.”
Read the source →Diners, Drive-Ins & DivesDiners, Drive-Ins & DivesTV Spotlight2008-03-14
Season 1, Episode 13
“St. Elmo Steak House featured for their famous shrimp cocktail and steaks in Indianapolis.”
Read the source →Man v. FoodMan v. FoodTV Spotlight2009-12-02
Season 2, Episode 2
“St. Elmo Steak House was featured on Man v. Food when Adam Richman visited Indianapolis and took on the shrimp cocktail. ”
Read the source →Reserve a table
At a glance
- Price
- $$$$
- Google rating
- 4.6 ★
- Critic mentions
- 3