Critics agree
3 critics
Updated August 2026
Who recommends it
Forbes TravelForbes Travel Guide4 Star2023-01-01
“St. Elmo Steak House receives Forbes Four-Star recognition as Indianapolis' legendary steakhouse known for its shrimp cocktail and prime steaks.”
Read the source →Triple DDiners, Drive-Ins & DivesTV Spotlight2008-04-21
Season 2, Episode 7
“St. Elmo Steak House featured for their famous shrimp cocktail and steaks in Indianapolis.”
Read the source →Man v. FoodMan v. FoodTV Spotlight2009-03-11
Season 2, Episode 8
“Adam Richman visited St. Elmo for their legendary spicy shrimp cocktail challenge.”
Read the source →Find a table
At a glance
- Price
- $$$$
- Google rating
- 4.6 ★
- Critics
- 3
Rating, price and photo data from Google.