Highly recommended
3 critic mentions
Updated August 2026
P
Critic Recognition
The InfatuationThe InfatuationHit List2023-05-16
“PopUp Bagels was featured on The Infatuation's NYC Hit List for serving fresh, piping-hot bagels paired with unique custom schmears.”
Read the source →Time OutTime OutBest New Restaurant2023-10-18
“Time Out listed PopUp Bagels among the best bagel shops in New York City for its crispy, warm-from-the-oven whole bagels.”
Read the source →EaterEaterEssential2023-11-01
“Eater NYC named PopUp Bagels to its essential list of the best bagel destinations across New York City.”
Read the source →Reserve a table
At a glance
- Price
- $
- Google rating
- 4.4 ★
- Critic mentions
- 3